http://www.computerandvideogames.com/453628/video-game-bafta-awards-all-the-winners/
The Last of Us again... It had great audio, but that really is the best thing I could say about it

, the controls sucked and you continually died until you found the
exact moment to move or whatever. Tomb Raider handled things like that so much better and was far more interesting despite having a much more 'gamey' story.